Debating Gender - A Study of Medieval and Contemporary Discussion in Islam

Nadia Harhash

Summary

This work is an in-depth examination of medieval and contemporary discussions of gender in Islam, focusing in particular on views of women.
Ms. Harhash wisely introduces the discussion by clarifying the legal status of women in medieval Islam, which provides a useful framework for her discussion.
While her sympathy clearly lies with Averroes, I was particularly impressed by the chapter on al Ghazali, which traces a nuanced picture of al Ghazali's approach to women, highlighting striking differences in his various works and connecting his (to the modern ear) unpalatable claims about women- to his embracement of Sufism.
While Ms. Harhash is attracted to the "progressive" view of Averroes, she offers a lucid analysis of his core egalitarian statements in the commentary on the Republic without omitting to point out that his philosophical position is in some tension with the more traditional position in forming his legal decisions.
Ibn Taymiyyah is probably the biggest villain in Ms. Harhash's narrative and is portrayed as a kind of antipode to Averroes.
With respect to modern discussion, she focuses on Nawal El Saadawi and Fatima Mernissi, where she situates the modern discussion vis a vis its medieval counterpart and highlights differences and commonalities.
Ms. Harhash does a good job showing how the critique of the oppression of women in modern days leads to the same question that she had already addressed in Averroes, namely whether a critique of unjust structures in contemporary Islamic societies can be separated from a critique of Islam itself.
Overall, the thesis is a remarkable achievement. Ms. Harhash reconstructs the medieval and modern discussion with intellectual confidence and independence and brings out similarities and differences that are genuinely illuminating.

Available since: 05/31/2024.

Print length: 108 pages.

Humanities & Social Sciences

Other books that might interest you

Daddy Was a Number Runner - A Novel

Louise Meriwether

This modern classic is "a tough, tender, bitter novel of a black girl struggling towards womanhood" in 1930s Harlem—with a foreword by James Baldwin (Publishers Weekly). 
 
 
 
Depression-era Harlem is home for twelve-year-old Francie Coffin and her family, and it's both a place of refuge and the source of untold dangers for her and her poor, working class family. The beloved "daddy" of the title indeed becomes a number runner when he is unable to find legal work, and while one of Francie's brothers dreams of becoming a chemist, the other is already in a gang. Francie is a dreamer, too, but there are risks in everything from going to the movies to walking down the block, and her pragmatism eventually outweighs her hope; "We was all poor and black and apt to stay that way, and that was that." 
 
 
 
First published in 1970, Daddy Was a Number Runner is one of the seminal novels of the black experience in America. The New York Times Book Review proclaimed it "a most important novel."

Show book

Reckon

Anonymous

“Reckon illuminates all that tries to hide.” — JAVIER ZAMORA, author of Solito: A Memoir
“Logan Phillips’s Reckon is a hell of a book... Arizona needs this book. America needs this book. You do too.” — ANDER MONSON, author of Predator: A Movie, a Memoir, an Obsession
In Reckon, artist Logan Phillips returns to the fabled town of Tombstone to face the history he was raised on as a boy—gunfights, outlaws, and Hollywood cowboys—for a new, personal confrontation with the West’s foundational mythology. This hybrid memoir also explores sexuality, whiteness, masculinity, parenting, and what it means to love a land rife with contradiction and “slathered in murder.”
As innovative as it is moving, this memoir is constructed of essays, photography, poetry, newspaper clippings from the Tombstone Epitaph Local Edition, and of course, movie screenplays. As he writes the characters of his past––including Youngfather and Teenme––Phillips finds the real history to be much more complex than the stories he was told. This is Tombstone in the 1980s and 90s, a century after the West’s most famous gunfight––a fifteen-second event still performed every day in historical reenactments––where Phillips’s father works as a historical exhibit designer at the Courthouse Museum and his uncle as a stuntman at Old Tucson Studios.
With an original, searing voice, Reckon is an essential answer to the tough questions of past and future, inheritance and reinvention, all from the perspective of a boy stuck in the middle.
NARRATED BY THE AUTHOR. Cover: art by Logan Phillips, design by Leigh McDonald.
“A full-throated consideration of the antecedent of sultry desert queerness—the cowboy.” — RAQUEL GUTIÉRREZ, author of Brown Neon
“Reckon implodes the braggadocio and myth of the gunslinging West.” — ANTHONY CODY, Whiting Award winner
“Flying through masculine silence, Reckon is the owl.” — SESSHU FOSTER, author of City of the Future

Show book

Hope for Ukraine - Stories of...

Kyle Duncan, Esther Fedorkevich

A Harrowing, Intimate Look into the Most Devastating War in Eight Decades 
 
Part narrative, part wartime dispatch, Hope for Ukraine transports you into the gritty reality of war-torn Ukraine--and the front lines of faith, survival, and miraculous intervention. From scrambling to escape the bombs leveling their neighborhoods to fleeing sex traffickers in the chaos of border crossings to rescuing orphans trapped by Russian tanks, these stunning firsthand accounts tell the stories of real Ukrainians enduring terrible hardships with grit and grace. 
 
Join bestselling writer Kyle Duncan and his co-author Esther Fedorkevich--both with deep family ties to Ukraine--as they take you inside the conflict with dramatic boots-on-the-ground stories and eyewitness accounts of Ukrainian refugees, aid workers, soldiers, and families affected by the conflict.  
 
As the world holds its collective breath, these stories reveal the unbreakable spirit of a nation under siege. Even amid the chaos and tragedy of Europe's largest war since World War II, God is indeed at work in redemptive ways.  
 
Authors' Proceeds to Support Ukraine's Refugees

Show book

Complete Guide to...

Fiona Cain

The Complete Guide to Branchio-Oto-Renal Syndrome (BORS)
Clear, practical information about a rare genetic disorder affecting the ears, neck, and kidneys.
Living with a rare condition like Branchio-Oto-Renal (BOR) Syndrome can feel overwhelming — especially when answers seem hard to find. This comprehensive, easy-to-read guide is here to change that.
Written with warmth, clarity, and deep understanding, The Complete Guide to Branchio-Oto-Renal Syndrome (BORS) offers reliable information, practical tools, and heartfelt support for every stage of the BOR journey — from diagnosis to adulthood.
Inside you’ll discover:
• Clear explanations of genetics, symptoms, and testing
• Guidance on hearing, kidney health, and surgeries
• Advice for school, teen life, and adult healthcare
• Insights on family planning, fertility, and emotional wellbeing
• Practical checklists, templates, and journal prompts
• Ways to connect with the global BOR community
A trusted guide giving parents, teens, and professionals the tools to face BORS with confidence and hope.
About the Author
Fiona Cain is a passionate advocate for the BOR Syndrome community, drawing on years of experience supporting families, raising awareness, and creating educational resources. She is the founder of the Branchio-Oto-Renal Syndrome Education Centre™, dedicated to helping people worldwide understand and navigate life with BOR Syndrome.
© 2025 Fiona Cain / Branchio-Oto-Renal Syndrome Education Centre™
All rights reserved. Trademark registration pending. Legal action will be taken if necessary.
Visit: www.branchiootorenalsyndrome.com

Show book

Trends and Debates in American...

Otto Federico von Feigenblatt

The volume covers a range of topics related to American education from a Hispanic point of view. Legislative intervention in the teaching of social studies in Florida, critical race theory in education, strengths and weaknesses of the decentralized American education system, and the higher education of Hispanics in the United States, are some of the topics explored. The volume concludes with a critical interpretation of the shortage of teachers in the State of Florida at a time of great socioeconomic and political polarization in the United States of America, as a representative case of the central debates in education of the second decade of the twenty-first century.

Show book

Settling the Score -- Part 5:...

Josh Hunter

How to break an arrogant jock? 
Coach Davis should be happy. His team is on a winning streak. And his arrogant star quarterback, Wade Johnson, has finally learned to shut up and do what he’s told. It turns out that all Wade needed was a firm hand... and the threat of blackmail. 
Now the coach has Wade in a special kind of training. Properly broken and conditioned, Wade is going to be one hell of a player. And an even better sex slave. 
There’s just one problem-- Wade is holding on to a secret. Someone else had already given the cocky straight boy a taste for being used and dominated. And no matter what the coach threatens, Wade won’t give up the guy’s name. 
The coach doesn’t like to share. So he’s going to find out who Wade is protecting. Wade’s got to learn that he has no one to turn to. No one to trust. No one who’s going to ride to his rescue. Wade’s got to learn that he belongs to the coach. 
And no one else. 
•First time gay BDSM high school jock punishment story•

Show book